Once the epicenter of big-game fishing, Peru’s Cabo Blanco Fishing Club lured marlin, movie stars, and record-breaking catches in the 1950s and 60s. Decades later, its bustling docks and famous waters have faded into a quieter legacy.

In its heyday, Cabo Blanco was a glamorous destination that drew icons like Ernest Hemingway, Marilyn Monroe, John Wayne, and Paul Newman. LIFE magazine photographer Frank Schershel captured stunning images of the club’s bustling docks, record-breaking catches, and stacks of marlin tails as trophies of the sport. Today, Cabo Blanco is a quieter place, now better known for surfing than sport fishing, and the only catches likely to be made are the small anchovies that once sustained its big-game legends.

Read the full article for the complete story and a closer look at this remarkable chapter in sportfishing history.

A 337-lb. tuna caught at Cabo Blanco, Peru by member of the Cabo Blanco Fishing Club, 1959.

Frank Schershel/Life Photo Collection/Shutterstock

Members of Cabo Blanco Fishing Club discussed equipment, Peru, 1959.

Frank Schershel/Life Photo Collection/Shutterstock

In the 1950s and 60s, the Cabo Blanco Fishing Club in Peru was considered one of the world’s premier destinations for sport fishing. Located where the cold Humboldt Current met the warm Pacific Equatorial Current, the area’s unique ecosystem attracted marlin, tuna, and other massive fish in extraordinary numbers. It was here in 1953 that Texas oilman Alfred C. Glassell Jr. landed a record-setting 1,560-pound black marlin, a feat that would forever cement Cabo Blanco’s legendary status and even be featured in the 1958 film adaptation of The Old Man and the Sea.

Members of the Cabo Blanco Fishing Club bringing home a big catch, Peru, 1959.

Frank Schershel/Life Photo Collection/Shutterstock

Members of the Cabo Blanco Fishing Club out on the sea, Peru, 1959.

Frank Schershel/Life Photo Collection/Shutterstock

But the abundance that made Cabo Blanco famous could not last forever. Overfishing of anchovies—the primary food source for the giant billfish — along with a devastating El Niño event and shifting political conditions, led to a rapid decline in the region’s fish populations. By 1970, the Cabo Blanco Fishing Club closed its doors as its waters were depleted and international tourism waned. What was once “Marlin Boulevard” became a shadow of its former self.