Our friend and photographer Joseph Beeching spends a day chasing birds and striped bass across Jamaica Bay with New York actor-turned-fly-fishing guide, Captain Brendan McCarthy.

Interview and photos by Joseph Beeching.

My friend Matt and I took an Uber to a marina in Brooklyn, a place Brendan had directed us to. Driving through the neighbourhood, with its warehouses and empty lots, felt like a scene from The Sopranos. The marina was deserted, not a soul in sight. It was just after 7am, the sky a solid sheet of cloud, rain coming and going in soft, cold waves. We were early, buzzing with a nervous excitement, not quite knowing what we'd gotten ourselves into. 

Then we saw an SUV barrelling toward us at a clip that seemed to match our own adrenaline. Matt and I exchanged a look. This must be our guy. 

And he was. Brendan stepped out with a charismatic energy that cut straight through the grey morning. After quick hellos, we followed him to the dock and onto his boat a 25-foot Contender that looked built for business. We pushed off, cruising out of the marina into the broad, flat expanse of Jamaica Bay. 

The boat was fast. The cold was an understatement. But the pure thrill of it, the planes roaring low overhead on their way into JFK, the skyline fading behind us, the bite of salt spray made the cold irrelevant. We were too excited to feel it. 

In under thirty minutes, we were where we needed to be. Brendan gave us the briefing. For stripers, he said, the key is the birds. Find the flocks working the water, and you'll find the fish. He stood with binoculars in hand, scanning the horizon, then pointed. He opened the throttle, surging us toward a smudge of birds in the distance with other boats already converging. Then he killed the engine, and we glided silently into position. 

And then just like that Matt was on. The rod bowed, line peeling off. A few tense, glorious minutes later, Brendan leaned out of the boat to grab the bass. Its flanks were a deep, moody silver, streaked with bold, black lines. It was a proper fish. 

Casting from a moving boat, with heavy rods and flies the size of small birds, was a humbling art. Our attempts were, to be kind, interpretive. Brendan was endlessly patient, tweaking our timing, our stance, our release. 

Eventually, I felt that electric tug, the line coming tight. The fish didn’t just fight, it ran, darted, and circled the boat with a dogged power that felt immense. After what felt like

a marathon. He picked my bass out of the water. The rush was instantaneous, pure. Ithink the first thing I gasped was, “How am I supposed to go back to trout after this?”

Joseph Beeching: What’s your origin story in fly fishing? 

Brendan McCarthy: I was working as an actor and bartender in nyc. Went to Yellowstone on vacation. Was mesmerized by all the fly casting. Bought Joan Wolff’s book and practiced on the jetty in Rockaway. Found a cheap boat and never looked back. 

Joseph Beeching: Can you introduce yourself and your work? 

Brendan McCarthy: My name is Capt Brendan McCarthy. I started as a full time Sw flyfishing guide out of Brooklyn NY around 1996. I eventually started fishing half the season out of Montauk NY. In the last handful of years, through the inspiration of 2 of my clients, chef Francis Mallmann and author Peter Kaminsky, I started designing and building Argentine Parrilla Grills for restaurants, hotels and residential customers. 

Joseph Beeching: What’s your personal backstory? 

Brendan McCarthy: I am originally from Boston Ma. Have lived in Utah and San Francisco before coming to NYC in 1991, to be an actor. Instead, I fell in love with Flyfishing and became a guide. For many years, I was the first and only Sw Flyfishing guide in Manhattan NY. I was extremely lucky to marry and raise 3 children in the city. None of them fish, but all have impressive and advanced degrees from exceptional colleges. This a lesson to any who turn their hobby into a job!! 

With the help of many dear friends, I was able to make a living and had the chance to fish all over the world. Cuba, Seychelles, Panama, Belize, Mexico, Montana,Brasil, Alaska, Bahamas etc many times each. With the help of legendary Guide Paul Dixon, I spent a lot of time doing charity work for both fisheries (www.bonefishtarpontrust.org) and for kids causes such as Cystic Fibrosis (www.redbone.org) 

Joseph Beeching: What do you fish from?

Brendan McCarthy: The boat is a 25 foot Contender Tournament series with a 300 hp Yamaha outboard 

Joseph Beeching: What is special about fishing in New York City? 

Brendan McCarthy: When I started fishing Jamaica Bay, and the advice of Legendary fly shop owner, John Fisher, there was no one there. It was so uncanny being surrounded by 8 million people, yet no one on the water. That part has changed immensely, but the fishing has only gotten better every year for 30 plus years. On top of a mass of Striped Bass that pass by on their annual migration, the last 5-10 years has brought incredible amounts of Bluefin tuna within sight of the shore. Where many areas once were very productive for both species, many are no longer, yet the NYC still is!! 

Joseph Beeching: What are the days you remember most clearly from the water? 

Brendan McCarthy: Sensory memories are legion and hard to choose. Often it is the days of thick fog and heavy rain that I remember,mostly because they are often extremely good fishing!, but also, you can’t see any buildings or planes so it feels like wilderness. Nature. And to add to sensory, we often fish right out against the runways at JFK, and for many years, the Concorde was still flying. I’ll never forget the incredible noise and vibrations these planes put off. 

Joseph Beeching: How would you describe the character of this place? 

Brendan McCarthy: Lastly, this NYC resource is urban, with all the things that go along with that. Planes crashing, bodies being found, presidents landing at JFK, and all sorts of celebrities and billionaires taking part. A National Park named Gateway NP where we are fishing. Brand new immigrants fishing for food and cabinet level politicians fishing with multiple boats following behind as “protection”. 

It is an area that was important in the beginnings of global flight for Howard Hughes and Emilia Earhart and many others. For centuries, the Lenape tribes lived, fished and hunted here, but then came Coney Islands amusement parks and freak shows. Many of the islands of the bay holding Speakeasies built by the Italian mobsters during the days of prohibition. 

It’s now what they call a “heavy usage area” but I think maybe it has always been. Did I mention the Pizza nearby? This is as much about a day of fishing here as the actual fishing itself!!